Toolkit
|
Connect

Feedback 101

Learn three kinds of feedback, sort example cards and ask for the kind you'd like more of.

Feedback 101 is a short explainer on the three kinds of feedback that Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen describe: appreciation, coaching and evaluation. The team sorts 12 example cards into the three kinds, looks at its own habits and ends with each person asking for the feedback they'd like more of.

Type
Explainer
Time
30 minutes
Group size
Up to 20 people
Best used as
Group learning

Trusted by teams at

Why it works

Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen sort feedback into three kinds: appreciation, coaching and evaluation (Thanks for the Feedback, 2014). Appreciation tells people they're seen and valued, coaching helps them learn and improve, and evaluation tells them where they stand. A conversation goes off course when the giver offers one kind and the receiver hears another, such as coaching heard as a poor rating. Because evaluation tends to drown out the other two, Stone and Heen suggest keeping evaluation and coaching in separate conversations.

Kim Scott describes good feedback as caring personally and challenging directly at the same time (Radical Candor, 2017). She advises leaders to ask for feedback before they give it, starting with a question such as “What could I do or stop doing that would make it easier to work with me?”

Feedback 101 builds on both books. The card sort gives the team shared words and practice at telling the kinds apart, and the habits check shows which kind people would like more of. The last step starts with the leader asking for feedback, so the team sees the habit before anyone tries it.

Use Feedback 101 when a team wants shared words for feedback before it practises giving it. Knowing the three kinds helps people ask for the feedback they need and give the kind a colleague is looking for.

What the team leaves with

The team shares words for three kinds of feedback and knows which kind each person would like more of. Each person leaves with one question to ask a colleague in the week ahead, and the leader has heard what would make them easier to work with.

Illustration of a woman with orange hair holding a tablet and giving a thumbs up.

It works best when

  • The team plans to give each other more feedback and wants shared words for it.
  • People would like more of one kind of feedback, such as appreciation or coaching.
  • Appraisals are coming up and the team wants to keep evaluation and coaching in separate conversations.

For a different goal

  • The team knows the three kinds and wants to practise in realistic situations. Use Feedback Scenarios.
  • You want to prepare one piece of feedback for a colleague. Use the Say It Card.

How to run it

Each step shows how long it takes, the questions or prompts to ask the team and what happens.

1
Remember good feedback
5 minutes
What's the most useful feedback you've had at work?

Share your own example first, then ask three people to share theirs. Note what made each one useful, such as its timing or how specific it was.

2
Meet the three kinds
5 minutes
Which kind was the feedback you remembered?

Explain Stone and Heen's three kinds. Appreciation says thank you and shows someone they matter. Coaching helps someone learn, grow or change. Evaluation tells someone where they stand against a standard or against others. Ask people which kind their example was, in the chat or with the person next to them.

3
Sort the cards
10 minutes
Which kind is this, and how can you tell?

In groups of four, people sort the 12 cards into the three kinds. Some cards carry more than one kind, so groups place those between two piles and say why. Ask each group to share the card they discussed longest.

4
Check your habits
5 minutes
Which kind do you give most, and which would you like more of?

Run two anonymous polls, one for each question, or ask people to write their answers down and compare them with the person next to them. Share the poll results and ask the team what it notices.

5
Ask for feedback
5 minutes
What could I do or stop doing that would make it easier to work with me?

Ask the team Kim Scott's question, listen and thank people for every answer. Online, people can answer in the chat. Next, each person writes one question asking a colleague for the kind of feedback they'd like more of, such as “What's one thing I could do to make my reports easier to use?”, to ask in the week ahead.

Materials

The Feedback 101 cards, one set for each group, printed and cut up or on a shared online whiteboard

Before you start

Print the feedback cards and cut them up, one set for each group, or paste the 12 lines onto a shared online whiteboard with three columns headed Appreciation, Coaching and Evaluation. Groups of four work best. Think of a useful piece of feedback you've had, so you can share yours first.

Plan a session

Add this tool to your session, then build a timed agenda in the Toolkit.

Add to your session
Canvas preview

Print the feedback cards.

The sheet holds 12 feedback cards to cut out and sort into appreciation, coaching and evaluation, with an answer key for the leader.

We'll email you the tool. You can unsubscribe from any email in one click. Read our privacy policy.

PDF · A4 · 1 page

Download the PDF →

Run this tool with your team

Add it to your session and the Toolkit builds a timed agenda around it.

Old template parts, hidden. Safe to delete once the new layout is approved.

Feedback 101

Learn three kinds of feedback, sort example cards and ask for the kind you'd like more of.

Feedback 101 is a short explainer on the three kinds of feedback that Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen describe: appreciation, coaching and evaluation. The team sorts 12 example cards into the three kinds, looks at its own habits and ends with each person asking for the feedback they'd like more of.

Type
Explainer
Time
30 minutes
Group size
Up to 20 people
Best as
Group learning
In depth

A little more detail.

Three people discussing colorful sticky notes on a transparent board in a teamwork session.
Outcomes

What you'll leave with.

Illustration of two people with orange backpacks viewed from behind, looking sideways and smiling.
BRIEF Facilitation notes

How to run it.

When to use it

Use it when

Not the right tool when

Use it with your team

This tool works best in a well-facilitated room.

Using this tool with a skilled facilitator means that discussions are focused, time is used efficiently, and the group moves toward consensus, making the session productive and impactful.

Downloads

Take it away and use it.

The canvas is free to download and use however suits you. If you want the full facilitator's guide to run the exercise properly, that sits inside the kit.

Related tools

Facilitator's guide

The canvas

Part of the