Mirror Test

See your weaknesses through a competitor's eyes.

Put yourself in the shoes of your competitor, or your opposite number. If you were them, and imagine they know everything about you and your weaknesses. What would they do with that information? How would they capitalise?

Type
Exercise
Time
30 minutes
Group size
4-12 people
Best as
Group exercise
In depth

A little more detail.

This is a technique from the book Winners, by Alistair Campbell. In the book, Campbell interviews football coach Jose Mourinho, and they talk about how to get ahead in a game where everything is analysed and shared and in the public knowledge.

Mourinho says: "Everyone knows everything about everybody, so you have to be cleverer in the analysis."

So - assume everyone knows everything the same. What would you do to get ahead? A technique Campbell suggests is called the Mirror Test. He talks about an example of when he was working for Tony Blair in the run-up to an
election.

He says of the opposition party: "If we were them analysing us, assuming they had the same information about us that we do, what would we do with that information?"

He says: "It was important that we were better at working out our weaknesses than they were, because then we could hopefully do something about fixing them before they got onto them."

So, we invite groups to try this for themselves. Subject yourself to brutal analysis. What are your weaknesses and how might you go about fixing them?

Do it for your business. Are there things you wouldn't want your competition to know about your situation? What can you do to fix them?

Outcomes

What you'll leave with.

BRIEF Facilitation notes

How to run it.

When to use it

Use Mirror Test to expose the weaknesses a competitor could exploit. Imagining a rival who knows everything about you, and asking what they would do with it, helps a team find and fix vulnerabilities before anyone else does.

Use it when

  • You want an honest, outside-in view of your weaknesses.
  • A team is too close to its own situation to see the risks.
  • Competitive pressure makes self-awareness urgent.

Not the right tool when

  • You want a full picture of the competition. Use Competitive Landscape.
  • The focus is internal strengths and weaknesses broadly. Use SWOT.
Used in

Workshops that feature this tool.

No items found.
Use it with your team

This tool works best in a well-facilitated room.

Using this tool with a skilled facilitator means that discussions are focused, time is used efficiently, and the group moves toward consensus, making the session productive and impactful.