Toolkit
|
Connect

Feedback Scenarios

Practise the everyday feedback that helps a colleague grow, from a specific thank-you to a next step.

Feedback Scenarios gives a team six short moments from working life, such as a colleague's first client presentation or a request for a view on a draft plan. In small groups, people agree what they'd say next to help their colleague grow, then try their words out on the rest of the team.

Type
Scenario
Time
30 minutes
Group size
Up to 20 people
Best used as
Skills practice

Trusted by teams at

Why it works

Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen describe three kinds of feedback (Thanks for the Feedback, 2014). Appreciation tells someone they're seen and valued, coaching helps them learn and grow, and evaluation tells them where they stand. Feedback Scenarios practises the first two, which colleagues can give each other every day.

Avraham Kluger and Angelo DeNisi pooled 607 results from 131 studies of feedback and found that feedback improved performance on average, and worked best when it kept people's attention on the task (Psychological Bulletin, 1996). The best responses on the sheet do the same: they name what the person did and what it led to, or the next thing to try.

The six scenarios cover a colleague's first client presentation, a teammate who stayed late to help, a new joiner's first report, a draft plan before it goes to the leadership team, a colleague who made the point that changed a decision and a manager who asks how she could help you do your best work. Practising on fictional colleagues lets the team find its words first, and the last step turns them into real feedback in the week ahead.

Use Feedback Scenarios when a team wants to practise feedback that helps colleagues grow, including the thanks that tells someone what to keep doing. The scenarios are about fictional colleagues, so people can find their words together before they use them for real.

What the team leaves with

The team leaves with a shared list of feedback written in its own words, from specific thanks to clear next steps. Each person has chosen one piece of feedback to give in the week ahead.

Illustration of a woman with orange hair holding a tablet and giving a thumbs up.

It works best when

  • The team wants feedback to become an everyday habit.
  • People want words for a thank-you that tells a colleague exactly what to keep doing.
  • New managers want to practise feedback before their first one-to-ones.

For a different goal

  • One person wants to prepare a piece of feedback for a particular colleague. Use the Say It Card.
  • The team wants to practise the responses that make it easy to speak up. Use Safety Scenarios.

How to run it

Each step shows how long it takes, the questions or prompts to ask the team and what happens.

1
Recall feedback that helped
5 minutes
What's the most useful feedback you've had at work, and what made it useful?

Ask three people to share. Note what made each piece useful, such as a specific example or a clear next step, and keep the list where everyone can see it.

2
Work the scenarios
12 minutes
What would you say next to help this colleague grow?

Give each group two scenarios from the sheet. For each one, the group agrees what they'd say next and writes it on the sheet in their own words.

3
Try the words out
8 minutes
How would this sound if you said it to your colleague today?

Each group reads out one scenario, and one person says the response aloud as they'd say it to the colleague. The rest of the team suggests one change that would make it clearer or warmer. Capture every response on a shared list.

4
Choose one to give
5 minutes
Who could you give some useful feedback to this week?

Each person chooses a colleague to give feedback to in the week ahead and picks the words from the list that fit. People share the words they'll use, without naming the colleague, in the chat or with the person next to them.

Materials

The Feedback Scenarios sheet, one for each group, printed or pasted into each online breakout group

Before you start

Print the scenario sheet for each group, or paste the scenarios into each online breakout group. Choose the scenarios closest to the team's own work, and give each group one thank-you and one next step. Groups of four work best.

Plan a session

Add this tool to your session, then build a timed agenda in the Toolkit.

Add to your session
Canvas preview

Print the scenario sheet.

Six feedback scenarios on one sheet, each with space for the group's response.

We'll email you the tool. You can unsubscribe from any email in one click. Read our privacy policy.

PDF · A4 · 1 page

Download the PDF →

Run this tool with your team

Add it to your session and the Toolkit builds a timed agenda around it.

Old template parts, hidden. Safe to delete once the new layout is approved.

Feedback Scenarios

Practise the everyday feedback that helps a colleague grow, from a specific thank-you to a next step.

Feedback Scenarios gives a team six short moments from working life, such as a colleague's first client presentation or a request for a view on a draft plan. In small groups, people agree what they'd say next to help their colleague grow, then try their words out on the rest of the team.

Type
Scenario
Time
30 minutes
Group size
Up to 20 people
Best as
Skills practice
In depth

A little more detail.

Three people discussing colorful sticky notes on a transparent board in a teamwork session.
Outcomes

What you'll leave with.

Illustration of two people with orange backpacks viewed from behind, looking sideways and smiling.
BRIEF Facilitation notes

How to run it.

When to use it

Use it when

Not the right tool when

Use it with your team

This tool works best in a well-facilitated room.

Using this tool with a skilled facilitator means that discussions are focused, time is used efficiently, and the group moves toward consensus, making the session productive and impactful.

Downloads

Take it away and use it.

The canvas is free to download and use however suits you. If you want the full facilitator's guide to run the exercise properly, that sits inside the kit.

Related tools

Facilitator's guide

The canvas

Part of the