Strategic Trade-Offs

What are we deliberately stepping back from?

The first session after lunch. Takes the Strategic Intent outputs and moves them from direction-setting into prioritisation, asking the team to make explicit decisions about what they will stop, reduce, or deprioritise in light of their chosen strategy.

Type
Exercise
Time
60 minutes
Group size
4-12 people
Best used as
Decision making

Trusted by teams at

Why it works

Every strategic choice creates a trade-off. Resources, attention, and capability are finite. This session makes those trade-offs explicit, using the Strategic Intent outputs as the reference point throughout.

Framing (10 min): The facilitator reconnects the group with their Strategic Intent outputs, focusing particularly on the Arena and Edge elements. The session's purpose is clarified: strategy only creates value when it shapes decisions about where effort actually goes.

Current activity audit (20 min): Working individually, participants list the initiatives, projects, activities, and investments the organisation (or team) is currently running. No filtering at this stage: the goal is a comprehensive picture of where time, money, and energy are going.

Mapping against Strategic Intent (20 min): Using a simple two-axis canvas (effort/cost versus strategic alignment), the group maps current activities. The Easy High Impact tool is used to focus attention: which activities are well-aligned and easy to sustain, which are misaligned and costly, and which sit in the uncomfortable middle?

The trade-off conversation (30 min): The group works through activities in the misaligned or low-priority quadrants. For each, they consider: stop, reduce, or continue with eyes open? The facilitator holds the Strategic Intent as the reference point throughout, preventing the conversation from defaulting to the familiar or the politically safe.

Capturing decisions (10 min): Decisions and next steps are documented. Not all trade-offs will be resolved in the session, but each is named, owned, and given a clear next action.

Use Strategic Trade-Offs when a team has set its direction and effort is still spread across too many initiatives. The team audits what it is currently running, maps each activity against the strategy, and decides openly what to stop, reduce or keep.

What the team leaves with

The team identifies which current activities, initiatives, and investments are misaligned with their strategy. They make explicit trade-off decisions instead of leaving them to default. They leave with a clear picture of where effort needs to shift.

Illustration of a woman with orange hair holding a tablet and giving a thumbs up.

It works best when

  • A team has set strategic direction and now needs to decide what to stop or reduce.
  • Effort is spread across too many initiatives and priorities are unclear.
  • You want to make trade-off decisions explicit instead of leaving them to default.

For a different goal

  • The team has not yet agreed its strategy. Run Strategic Intent first.
  • There is no real list of current activities to examine.

How to run it

Each step shows how long it takes, the questions or prompts to ask the team and what happens.

1
5 minutes

Reconnect the group with the strategic direction they have already set, focusing on where they have chosen to compete and where their advantage lies. Strategy only creates value when it shapes where effort actually goes.

2
15 minutes

Working individually, people list every initiative, project, and investment currently running. No filtering yet: the goal is a complete picture of where time and money go.

3
15 minutes

Using a two-axis canvas of effort against strategic alignment, the group maps current activities and sees which are well-aligned, which are costly and misaligned, and which sit in the middle.

4
20 minutes

Work through the misaligned and low-priority activities. For each, decide: stop, reduce, or continue with eyes open? Hold the agreed strategy as the reference point throughout.

5
5 minutes

Document the decisions and next steps. Each trade-off is named, owned, and given a clear next action.

Materials

Flipchart, sticky notes, marker pens

Before you start

This is the move from direction into prioritisation. Given what the group has said it wants to do and where it has chosen to compete, the session asks the hard question of what to stop, reduce, or deliberately deprioritise.

Plan a session

Add this tool to your session, then build a timed agenda in the Toolkit.

Add to your session

Run this tool with your team

Add it to your session and the Toolkit builds a timed agenda around it.

Old template parts, hidden. Safe to delete once the new layout is approved.

Strategic Trade-Offs

What are we deliberately stepping back from?

The first session after lunch. Takes the Strategic Intent outputs and moves them from direction-setting into prioritisation, asking the team to make explicit decisions about what they will stop, reduce, or deprioritise in light of their chosen strategy.

Type
Exercise
Time
60 minutes
Group size
4-12 people
Best as
Decision making
In depth

A little more detail.

Three people discussing colorful sticky notes on a transparent board in a teamwork session.
Outcomes

What you'll leave with.

Illustration of two people with orange backpacks viewed from behind, looking sideways and smiling.
BRIEF Facilitation notes

How to run it.

When to use it

Use it when

Not the right tool when

Use it with your team

This tool works best in a well-facilitated room.

Using this tool with a skilled facilitator means that discussions are focused, time is used efficiently, and the group moves toward consensus, making the session productive and impactful.

Downloads

Take it away and use it.

The canvas is free to download and use however suits you. If you want the full facilitator's guide to run the exercise properly, that sits inside the kit.

Related tools

Facilitator's guide

The canvas

Part of the